Tough Decisions

Would You Rehire?

November 02, 2026•3 min read

Knowing What You Now Know, Who Would Not Hire Into Your Company?

Every leader accumulates scar tissue.

After enough years in business, you stop measuring success solely by the great hires you made and begin evaluating yourself by the costly mistakes you could have avoided. The candidates who dazzled during interviews but failed in execution. The executives with impressive résumés who left a trail of dysfunction. The technically brilliant contributors who poisoned culture.

If you could travel back in time with everything you know today, who would never receive an offer letter?

The answer reveals far more than the individual. It reveals what you've learned about leadership.

The Resume Trap

Most hiring errors begin with credentials.

A candidate arrives with the right schools, the right companies, the right titles, and glowing references. On paper, they appear overqualified.

Yet within months, something goes wrong.

The problem is that résumés tell us where someone has been. They rarely tell us how they behaved while they were there.

We've all encountered the executive who claims responsibility for every success and attributes every failure to external circumstances. The manager who presents well upward but struggles to build followership. The salesperson who exceeds quota while leaving a wrecked team behind.

Experience matters. Character matters more.

The People I Wouldn't Hire Again

Over time, I've become less concerned with what candidates know and more concerned with how they operate.

Knowing what I know now, I would hesitate to hire:

People who consistently blame others.

Accountability is not a skill. It's a habit. Individuals who always have an explanation for why something went wrong rarely become the leaders who solve problems.

People who confuse activity with results.

Some professionals are extraordinarily busy. Their calendars are full. Their presentations are polished. Their updates are frequent.

Yet the outcomes never seem to arrive.

Organizations don't need more motion. They need progress.

People who cannot accept feedback.

The most dangerous employees are not those who make mistakes. Everyone makes mistakes.

The dangerous ones are convinced they don't.

People who create dependency instead of capability.

Strong leaders develop people. Weak leaders create followers who can't function without them.

One model scales. The other becomes an organizational bottleneck.

People whose values change with the audience.

Integrity is consistency under pressure. If someone's principles seem to shift depending on who is in the room, trust eventually disappears.

What Great Hiring Really Is

The best hiring decisions are not about selecting the most impressive candidate.

They are about identifying the candidate most likely to succeed within your environment while strengthening your culture.

That requires asking different questions:

  • How do they handle adversity?

  • How do former colleagues describe them when they're not present?

  • What mistakes have they made?

  • What did they learn from those mistakes?

  • Would people willingly follow them again?

Those answers are often more predictive than degrees, certifications, or previous titles.

The Ultimate Test

I've come to believe there's one question that cuts through almost everything else:

Would I enthusiastically hire this person a second time?

Not because they are likable.

Not because they are smart.

Not because they interview well.

Would I hire them again knowing everything I know today?

The organizations that consistently make great hiring decisions are not the ones that never make mistakes. They're the ones that learn from them. They develop a clearer picture of what excellence looks like and an equally clear picture of what it doesn't.

Every bad hire is tuition.

The real return on that investment arrives when you stop paying for the same lesson twice.


The best leaders keep a mental list of great hires and regrettable hires. Which characteristics appear repeatedly on both lists? The patterns may tell you more about your hiring process than any assessment tool ever could.

Back to Blog